Sympathy for the Devil

Jesus, bearing the cross to Golgotha
Odd John just can't play well with the synoptic kids. He describes Jesus as the bread of life in Capernaum, several chapters before this Passover meal. Here, bread (consecrated?) is primarily used to implicate Judas ... by intinction, no less. So for Judas, the first Eucharist becomes a Black Mass. He takes the bread from Jesus, an outward and visible sign...

Share This Post

Jesus, bearing the cross to Golgotha

The one whom Jesus loved. The one who would deny him. The one who would betray him. Which one am I? Today, I mean.

Odd John just can’t play well with the synoptic kids. He describes Jesus as the bread of life in Capernaum, several chapters before this Passover meal. Here, bread (consecrated?) is primarily used to implicate Judas … by intinction, no less. So for Judas, the first Eucharist becomes a Black Mass. He takes the bread from Jesus, an outward and visible sign that “Satan entered into him,” and in a reversal of our own post-communion prayers, Jesus sends him out to do the work “that you are going to do.”

And after this disturbing scene — almost as a result, the way it’s written — Jesus says he has been glorified and God glorified in him.

We revile Judas, of course. Christians have used lazy readings of John’s Gospel to revile “the Jews,” too. We love Jesus, so we hate those who hate him, right? Isn’t that how love “works”?

When I think of the “Christ-killer!” slur presaging so much anti-Semitic violence, and even of the hook-nose caricature we’ve made of Judas, I want to ask: What? We’d prefer Christ hadn’t died for our sins? Or we just want it both ways: to be redeemed but still have someone to hate?


Wednesday, March 23, 2016
Isaiah 50:4-9
Psalm 70
Hebrews 12:1-3
John 13:21-32

More To Explore

Earth from Artemis II, Day 2
Newsletter

Parish News: April 26

In this week’s newsletter, Mother Liz celebrates Earth Month alongside Eastertide, noting how resurrection speaks not only to humanity but to “the groaning of the whole creation” and God’s determination to make all things new. She observes that when Mary Magdalene mistakes the risen Christ for a gardener, we glimpse the deep interconnection of all beings—and when we touch creation’s wounds with reverence and compassion, we meet God. Quoting Robin Wall Kimmerer, the rector reminds us that “when we work to heal the earth, the earth heals us,” and invites us to deepen our love and commitment to our fragile, beautiful planet.

Read More →